Which Cookies Ship Well or Poorly? My Quick-Reference Cheat Sheet

12 Cookies That Ship Beautifully: My Tested Mail-Order Cookie List

Let me tell you about the Great Cookie Catastrophe of last December, which is what my sister now refers to as “the incident.” I shipped my college roommate a box of gorgeous, perfectly iced sugar cookies — little snowflakes, mittens, the whole festive lineup. She called to ask if I had intentionally sent her a … Read more

No-Fail Thumbprint Cookies Kids Love to Make: Our Rainy Day Tradition

No-Fail Thumbprint Cookies Kids Love to Make: Our Rainy Day Tradition

It was a Tuesday in November, the rain was coming down sideways, and my seven-year-old had already asked me “what can we do?” approximately forty-seven times before 10 a.m. So I did what any reasonable cookie-obsessed parent would do — I handed him an apron and said, “We’re making thumbprint cookies.” What followed was one … Read more

Sugar Cookie Decorating Party: How I Hosted 12 Kids Without Losing My Mind

Sugar Cookie Decorating Party: How I Hosted 12 Kids Without Losing My Mind

I almost cancelled the whole thing the night before. It was 10 p.m., I had a double batch of sugar cookie dough chilling in the fridge, and I had just discovered — in absolute horror — that I’d forgotten to buy any powdered sugar. Zero. None. For the royal icing. For a cookie decorating party … Read more

Energy Ball Cookies vs No-Bake Oat Cookies: I Made Both Every Week for a Month

Energy Ball Cookies vs No-Bake Oat Cookies: I Made Both Every Week for a Month

I did not intend to become a no-bake cookie scientist. But there I was, three weeks into my self-imposed experiment, standing in my kitchen at 11 p.m. with oat mixture coating both forearms up to my elbows, a rogue chocolate chip stuck to my cheek, and seventeen lopsided blobs that refused to hold their shape … Read more